Choosing Character Over Charisma

· Study Guides

Scripture Focus: 1 Samuel 16:7

But the LORD said to Samuel, ‘Do not consider his appearance or his height, for I have rejected him. The LORD does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart.’

We live in a world that is captivated by image. We applaud charisma, gravitate toward confidence, and often assume that if someone looks the part, they must be right for the role. But in 1 Samuel 16:7, God gently corrects this mindset, even in His own prophet, Samuel.

Samuel was ready to anoint Eliab as the next king of Israel based on appearance and stature. Eliab looked strong, confident, and every bit like a king. But God saw something deeper; something invisible to the human eye. God rejected Eliab and instead chose David, the youngest son, the forgotten shepherd boy. Why? Because while people look at outward appearances, God looks at the heart.

Section image

This should challenge how we view others and how we view ourselves. It reminds us not to be drawn in by surface-level charm or polished performance. Someone can speak well, look confident, and shine brightly in public, yet still carry hidden struggles or misaligned motives in their heart. God is not moved by style without substance. He is drawn to integrity, to humility, and to a heart that genuinely seeks after Him.

Likewise, you may feel overlooked, underestimated, or unqualified. But if your heart is right before God, you are exactly the kind of person He uses. God doesn’t need you to be the most charismatic because He is looking for someone with character.

Key Lessons From the Passage

a. God’s standard is different from ours - We tend to elevate charisma, talent, and appearance. God prioritizes humility, purity, and sincerity.

b. Outward success does not equal spiritual strength - Someone may sound impressive or appear spiritual, but God examines motives, intentions, and private devotion.

c. Being overlooked does not mean being rejected by God - David was left in the field, forgotten by his family, yet chosen by God. Your value is not determined by who sees you, but by the God who knows your heart.

d. God uses those with the right heart, not the best resume - God doesn’t need you to be the most talented. He is looking for willing, obedient, God-seeking hearts.

Reflection Questions

Use these prompts to guide personal study or group discussion:

  1. What qualities do I tend to value in others? Are they aligned with God’s priorities?
  2. Have I ever judged someone based on their appearance or charisma? What did I overlook?
  3. In what ways do I struggle with feeling overlooked or unqualified?
  4. What does my heart reveal about my walk with God?
  5. How can I cultivate integrity, humility, and a genuine desire to please God?

Practical Application

  1. Spend time this week examining your motives in areas where you serve or lead.
  2. Ask God to reveal anything in your heart that needs to be refined.
  3. Look beyond surface-level traits in others, and seek to recognize godly character.
  4. Practice affirming qualities in people that God values, not what culture celebrates.

Prayer:

Lord, help me to value what You value. Teach me not to be impressed by appearances, but to seek and cultivate a heart of integrity. Remove every desire for superficial approval and let my life reflect Your priorities, and not the world’s. Amen.

Author: Kimberly A.S. Williams